[Urbanstudy] Semantics Ist Challenge to Modi’s ‘Smart Cities’

Vinay Baindur yanivbin at gmail.com
Sat Aug 30 08:52:27 CDT 2014


Semantics Ist Challenge to Modi’s ‘Smart Cities’

By Devirupa Mitra

Published: 30th August 2014 06:00 AM

Last Updated: 29th August 2014 11:12 PM


SINGAPORE:  Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s pet project for 100 smart cities
needs Singapore to be in the director’s chair. But, both still have to
grapple with the first step that will define the whole project-- how to
define a smart city?

Since Modi came to power three months ago, the South-East Asian nation was
also quick on the take, with three major bilateral visits already taking
place. And discussions on ‘smart cities’ was the common thread running
through them.

But, there is a lot of gap to bridge before the collaboration can take off.
So far during preliminary talks, it has become quite evident that it means
different things for Singapore and India.

“We got the impression that Indian officials think of smart cities in terms
of IT-fying, broadband, fibre optics,” said a senior Singaporean government

In contrast, the starting point of the city state’s concept of a ‘smart
city’ is the environment. “Remember, we never call Singapore a smart city.
We call it a garden city,” he said.

The other pillar of a ‘smart city’ is “good governance”.

“Even if the infrastructure built is great, it doesn’t matter if from the
Chief Minister down to the lowest official don’t know how to run it,” said
the Singaporean official.

So the first step is to thrash out the concept of the ‘smart city” with
urban development experts from both the countries. And this will be
followed by the drawing up of the master plan, consultancy and components
of foreign investment.

“PM Modi has to get one city off the ground,” he said.  The NDA Government
had earmarked `7,060 crore for the smart cities’ plan in its maiden Union
Budget, which is clearly only for the preliminary stage.

According to Singapore Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ ambassador-at-large,
Gopinath Pillai, it is doable, as long as the parameters are set out.

“It (smart cities) is a feasible concept, as long as you clearly define
what it means,” Pillai,seated at the colonial-era redolent Singapore
Cricket Club, said.

The Prime Minister had made his first visit to Singapore in 2004 at the
invitation of Pillai, who is also chairman of National University of
Singapore’s Institute of South Asian Studies.

“It had raised eyebrows then.. but I saw signs of business vibrancy in
Gujarat,” he recalled.

Pillai, who is a doyen of Singapore’s foreign policy establishment, said
that Narendra Modi, who has visited the city state thrice, is probably
impressed with the stress on enforcement of rules.

“You have so many rules, but they are not implemented,” he said.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.mail.sarai.net/pipermail/urbanstudygroup_mail.sarai.net/attachments/20140830/b4e2b3e1/attachment.html>

More information about the Urbanstudygroup mailing list